Reliable Security Information


The F-22 is Not Dead Yet: Congress Should Support the Development of an Allied Variant

The U.S. Senate appropriations committee recently approved its version of the fiscal year (FY) 2010 defense spending bill, and the legislation now awaits floor time in the full Senate. Section 8056 of the bill includes authorization for the U.S. Air Force to use appropriated funds to develop an export, or allied, variant of the F-22A Raptor. Members of the House of Representatives approved the opposite in the House-passed FY10 defense spending bill by reiterating support for the long-standing Obey amendment and denying the use of funds to develop an allied variant.


As John Donnelly reports in a CQ story on August 24, "Export Sales of F-22 Fighters Not Likely, Some Supporters Say," Representative David Obey (D-WI) "continues to oppose foreign sales, his spokesman said, and every Defense appropriations act since fiscal 2008 has contained a provision barring the use of any funds to export the warplane." Once this bill moves into conference negotiations between the two chambers of Congress, members should assume the Senate's wise position and fund an export version of the F-22.


The F-22 Has No Peer


The F-22 is the world's most advanced fifth-generation fighter aircraft. The F-22 offers several unique features: thrust-vectoring engines, which make it highly maneuverable; the latest in stealth technology; an avionics system that can fuse information into a single display; and the ability to cruise at supersonic speeds at 50,000 feet. What makes the Raptor spectacular--and why its capabilities cannot simply be replaced by additional F-35 Joint Strike Fighters--is the F-22A's unique ability to accelerate beyond the threat and reposition for attack.


Naturally, Congress is protective of these unrivaled technologies. Even though core allies like Japan and Australia have repeatedly expressed interest in purchasing a modified version of the F-22, Congress has yet to produce a final bill that waives legislation preventing the aircraft from being exported.


Benefits of Sale to Trusted Allies


The continued growth of China's defense budget and the technological advancements of its People's Liberation Army (PLA) have alarmed many of America's allies in the western Pacific, prompting them to invest in expanding their own military capabilities.


Since 1998, various allies have inquired about purchasing the F-22. Japan has been the most vocal, persistently lobbying the U.S. government for the opportunity to acquire the aircraft to replace its aging fleet of F-4 Phantoms. A major air combat capability review conducted by the Australian Department of Defence in 2008 also analyzed the benefits of purchasing the F-22. Although Australia's 2009 Defence White Paper proposed buying 100 F-35 Joint Strike Fighters, many analysts believe Australia would be interested in taking advantage of the joint air dominance capabilities provided by the tandem operation of the F-22 and F-35 aircraft if the F-22 were available for export. South Korea and Israel have also shown interest in the Raptor.


With the F-22 line set to permanently close down in December 2011 if Congress does not purchase additional aircraft, the window for developing a variant of the F-22 that may be sold to allies in the Pacific, including possibly South Korea, is rapidly closing. A modified F-22 would provide these countries with the most advanced fighter on the market and help reinforce America's hedging strategy in the region by increasing interoperability with U.S. military forces. Foreign sales of the F-22 would also reduce the unit cost of the aircraft, potentially paving the way for the procurement of additional F-2As to help fulfill the Air Force's military requirement of 243 aircraft.

Outdated Thinking


The original concerns that prompted Congress to prevent the export of the F-22--the need for America to retain its fighter aircraft technological edge--no longer outweigh the two pressing demands: increasing the air superiority capability of America's Asian allies and retaining a national option to keep the production line open should Congress authorize production of more F-22s in the future.


Hedging against the medium- and long-term implications of China's military modernization will remain a critical component of America's strategy in the Pacific. Selling the F-22 to core allies that share both America's values and interests, like Japan and Australia (and even South Korea), will only contribute to this effort.


Moreover, the U.S.'s relationship with both countries has only deepened in the past decade as concerns over North Korea's nuclear program and China's growing military have drawn their interests closer to those of the U.S. Finally, an allied variant F-22 by default would be designed to alleviate the original concern of giving away too much critical technology.


The Window Is Closing


Congress has an opportunity in the pending FY 2010 defense appropriations bill to advance a series of mutually reinforcing goals that will contribute to American national security. While the original ban may have been prudent during the post-Cold War period of the 1990s, America's stronger relationships with Japan and Australia--coupled with the growing sophistication of China's PLA--have raised the stakes in the Pacific. Ensuring a stable balance of power in the region to hedge against uncertainty and stave off miscalculation demands that America's allies have the opportunity to field the most advanced fifth-generation platform on the market.


Studying the feasibility and cost of an F-22 allied variant is critical as well for America's shrinking aerospace industrial base. An allied variant in full-rate production for multiple countries would keep most elements of the F-22A production line "hot" for the next decade. Keeping the production open will result in greater efficiency and a reduced per unit cost--thereby creating an opportunity for Congress to purchase the 40 additional Raptors needed to meet the Air Force's "medium" risk air superiority requirement.


Congress is faced with a decision that stands to impact the next 30 years of U.S. air power and strategy in the Pacific. The unique opportunity now exists to significantly enhance the military capacity of America's closest allies in the Pacific. Congress should seize this moment and reward allies like Japan, Australia, and possibly South Korea with the option to purchase the F-22.

Comments (5)

Anonymous:

Another advantage of the F-22 is it is designed to be stealthy from many aspects whereas the F-35 stealth capability is mainly related to low frontal observability against X-band radar. A stealth design to beat X-band radars will lose effectiveness in the lower S-band and become even less effective in the L-band. L-Band AESA radars could be deployed on the Su-35 in as little as 3 years. Since L-band is cheaper to manufacture than X-band, older Flankers could theoretically be retrofitted for as little as $1 million. L-band would triple the range at which a Flanker could detect an F-35, which is not able to turn and run from such a threat.

Jacob:

Perhaps....but the procurement of F-22's should also be taken in the wider political context, namely what is the likelihood that a war with China is going to happen? Given that the U.S. didn't intervene in Georgia, it doesn't seem like we'd get involved in a shooting war with China over something like the Spratly Islands. More likely an international coalition would issue a condemnation of any Chinese aggression and maybe freeze relations. Sure it won't pack any military teeth, but China is certainly an internationally-minded country at this point and such a UN resolution would hurt and deter them. It took somebody as extreme as Adolf Hitler to shatter the international peace in 1939, and China doesn't seem anywhere near that just yet. The Chinese Communist government isn't particularly well-liked, and there are signs that their iron grip is faltering. If America took this much flak over invading Afghanistan and Iraq, then the Chinese government will have hell to pay from a globalized international community if it tries to attack Taiwan, and perhaps domestically as well. That said, our military is still more than capable enough to draw blood against China and offer some deterrence from starting a conflict in the first place.

JohnWCollins:

We need more F-22As. We should build 650 or whatever the number we planned back when we selected the YF-22. It is a great fighter and can ensure air-superiority for decades to come. The F-35 does not cut it in this role, and should not be viewed as a replacement for F-15s.

We cannot know the future and we must prepare for the worst. At the rate the government is wasting countless dollars on entitlement programs, pork stimulus projects, and countless other areas, we can certainly afford more aircraft key to this nations future national defense.

Our nation needs to get back on track in many different ways. Our economy is in bad shape, we are trillions in debt, our society has lost it's values and continues to rot, and our military needs an overhaul. By continuing F-22A production, even at a low rate, we can take a step towards correcting one of these problems.

Anonymous:

JohnWCollins, don't just look at the American military in isolation. It is rediculous not to allow a modified Raptor to be sold to our closest allies like Australia, Japan and South Korea. This could mean a lot of export dollars.

Ben:

If America wants to go to war over Taiwan China will oblige though China will continue with Diplomacy to swallow Taiwan. Read your history , Chan Kai Check ran away with the gold and Taiwan was historically part of China. It is part of their civil war.

Now they can nullify our carrier groups there is not much we can do without huge losses.

Guaranteeing Taiwan is the #1 issue stopping China becoming more friendly to the US . Its like France and Britain Guaranteeing the Confederate states in the US civil war it doesnt make people very happy.

Leave a comment

 
Subscribe to SitRep:
GlobalSecurity.org SitRep RSS Feed GlobalSecurity.org SitRep ATOM Feed