By a vote of 71 to 26, the U.S. Senate has voted to ratify the New START agreement. More importantly, it was a "clean" ratification, without any amendments or reservations to the text of the treaty itself.
The treaty could now be taken up by the Russian Duma in the next forty-eight hours, before its autumn session is concluded on December 24th (Christmas is celebrated in Russia on the Julian calendar, so there will be no objections to taking up business on what would be Christmas Eve on the Gregorian calendar).
In its resolution confirming ratification, the Senate did codify the U.S. understanding of the preamble--that it does not legally constrain the United States from moving ahead with missile defense--and, as Senator Bob Corker (R-TN) has noted, the president is required to notify the Russians "that continued development and deployment of U.S. missile defense systems do not threaten the strategic balance with Russia and consequently do not constitute a basis to withdraw from the treaty."
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov welcomed the Senate's decision but noted, "The [foreign] ministry and the parliament, we need some time to study the documents of the US ratification." But it seems unlikely that Moscow would jeopardize the pact over this issue, especially since the language of the treaty was left untouched.
Once the treaty is ratified by the Russian side, the question is then left on the table: does New START represent the "high-water mark" both of the U.S.-Russia "reset" and of President Obama's efforts to eliminate nuclear weapons?
Authors
- Richard Andres
- Benjamin Bahney
- Cheryl Benard
- Bruce Bennett
- Linda Bishai
- Jonah Blank
- Tim Brown
- James Jay Carafano
- Steven R. Charbonneau
- Christopher Chivvis
- Lindsay Clutterbuck
- Sam Cohen
- James L. Cook
- Walton Cook
- Ed Corcoran
- Ralph Cossa
- Council on Foreign Relations
- Rafiq Dossanip
- Charles Dunlap
- Amitai Etzioni
- Gareth Evans
- Nikolas K. Gvosdev
- Larry Hanauer
- Scott Warren Harold
- Brian Michael Jenkins
- David Johnson
- Terrence Kelly
- Michael Krepon
- Stephen Larrabee
- Mackenzie Eaglen
- Jeffrey Martini
- Arthur G. Martirosyan
- Ralph Masi
- Ali Nader
- Aram Nerguizian
- Ori Nir
- Olga Oliker
- Jim Phillips
- Isaac R Porche
- James T. Quinlivan
- Reset Defense Bulletin
- Charles Ries
- RSIS
- Paul Saunders
- David Schenker
- Ghassan Schbley
- Mark Schneider
- Daniel Serwer
- George Smith
- Scott Snyder
- Jon Soltz
- Julie Taylor
- Alexander Thier
- Charles P. Vick
- Rosemary Freitas Williams
- Charles Wolf, Jr.
- Elizabeth Zolotukhina